You don’t need $10k coaching programs or manipulative marketing to create a sustainable healing business.
As a holistic professional with 12 years of experience in the self-employed world, I’ve seen my fair share of marketing tactics – the good, the bad, and the downright manipulative. I’m writing this article because I’m fed up. Fed up with unethical, overpriced marketing coaches who prey on vulnerable business owners struggling to make ends meet. I’ve been there, fallen for their promises, and learned the hard way that there’s a better path.
When we’re drowning in to-do lists, struggling to balance client care with self-care, and watching our bank accounts with growing anxiety, it’s all too easy to fall prey to the siren song of quick fixes and overnight success promises. The desperation that comes with feeling overwhelmed can cloud your judgement, making those flashy high-ticket coaching programs seem like lifelines rather than potential anchors.
The truth I’ve discovered on my own bumpy journey: there’s a better way to grow our heart-centred businesses, one that honours our sensitivity and aligns with our values. I want to share with you why high-ticket coaching often misses the mark for practitioners like us, and how we can find a more authentic path to growing a sustainable business.
This is my story, my rant, and my plea for a more conscious approach to business coaching. If you’re a sensitive, holistic business owner like me, or if you’ve ever felt pressured by high-ticket marketing tactics, this is for you. Let’s pull back the curtain on these manipulative practices and explore what truly ethical marketing looks like.
Whilst I have no intention of branching out into teaching others how to run their business (this just isn’t my calling) however I am dedicated to helping other business owners like me connect with their authenticity, and support them towards more authenticity, calm and spaciousness.
My Rollercoaster Ride: 12 Years as a Holistic Entrepreneur
I am 12 years into working as a self employed holistic professional. There have been a lot of ups and downs, both work focus wise and financially. However I have managed to keep my business afloat despite the lockdowns of 2020 forcing me to move all of my in person offerings online (this turned out to be a blessing), many changes of business directions, and managing the complex balancing of running a demanding business and raising two neurodivergent children.
I am a multi-passionate woman. I cannot just do one thing in my work or only use one approach, it is far too boring for me. I have ADHD and I thrive on novelty, learning, and exploration. Of course my business has constantly evolved. I started as a doula, antenatal teacher, and babywearing instructor. Over the years, I learnt a ton of new skills, found myself starting to share these with others, and moved from teaching parents to teaching birth and holistic professionals. I have taught over 12 different types of courses and workshops, both in person and online. I have written 2 books and I’m about to launch a group program to support sensitive holistic professional women to overcome overwhelm.
My journey as a self-employed practitioner has been a rollercoaster of learning experiences, with burnout as an unwelcome frequent visitor. In my first year as a doula, I naively dove in headfirst, taking on more clients than I could handle. I grossly underestimated the emotional and energetic toll of pouring my heart and soul into supporting new mothers.
Fast forward a few years, and there I was again, teetering on the edge of burnout. This time, I found myself caught in the classic entrepreneur’s trap – working myself to the bone, watching my bank account dwindle, and feeling utterly clueless about how to break the cycle.
Enter the siren call of high-ticket coaching. You know the type – glossy programs that speak directly to your deepest insecurities, your financial fears, and your desperate desire for a solution. They dangle the carrot of a six-figure income in just a few months, if only you follow their “foolproof” formula. In my overwhelmed, financially stressed state, it seemed like a lifeline.
High ticket coaches are the flashy sports cars of the coaching world – all shine and promises, but often lacking in substance. These are the folks who charge eye-watering amounts for their programs, thousands or even tens of thousands of pounds. They market themselves as the crème de la crème, the only solution to your business woes. Their sales pitches are slick, promising rapid transformations and six-figure incomes in mere months.
The high price tag often has more to do with clever marketing than actual value. These coaches prey on your desperation, your dreams, and yes, even your trauma. They use high-pressure tactics, false scarcity, and grandiose promises to convince you that their overpriced program is the magic bullet you need. But remember, in the world of coaching, a higher price doesn’t necessarily mean better results – it just means a bigger dent in your bank account.
When I hired one of these high-ticket coaches, a little voice in my gut whispered that this wasn’t aligned with my values. But desperation has a way of drowning out intuition, doesn’t it? So I dove in, working with this coach for several intense months.
On the surface, it seemed to be working – my visibility increased, and I was ‘putting myself out there’. But beneath that veneer of progress, the cracks were starting to show. My overwhelm skyrocketed. What I didn’t realise then (but know now) was that I’m neurodivergent (Neurodivergent people often get more easily overwhelmed than neurotypical ones), which added an extra layer of challenge to an already unsustainable situation.
I’ve always been the type to set sky-high expectations for myself. It’s like I have an internal taskmaster that never sleeps, constantly pushing for more. Working with this coach amplified that inner critic, increasing the pressure I was already putting on myself.
When I look back (hindsight is such a wonderful thing isn’t it?), I can see that it was unethical that this coach never once asked about my life outside of business. How many hours could I realistically dedicate to the program? What other commitments was I juggling? What was my personal situation? And crucially, how long would it actually take to implement all their ‘foolproof’ strategies? These questions were never even on the table.
Instead, I was handed a social media schedule that would make even the most seasoned influencer break out in sweat. It was like being asked to run a marathon when I was already gasping for air. The guilt started creeping in – every time I couldn’t tick off all the boxes on the coach’s to-do list, I felt like I was failing.
What had started as a lifeline was quickly becoming an anchor, dragging me deeper into the overwhelm I was desperately trying to escape.
The aftermath of my high-ticket coaching experience wasn’t pretty. It took two solid years and the guidance of a more holistic marketing coach to unravel the pressure, stress, guilt, and misalignment that had tangled up my business and my mind.
Thankfully, the story takes a turn for the better. A few years down the line, I stumbled upon a marketing mentor, George Kao, who felt like a breath of fresh air in the stale, overpriced world of business coaching. This person was the real deal – truly ethical, authentic to their core, and completely aligned with my values as a holistic practitioner. The cherry on top? Their courses were actually affordable.
I’m sharing my journey – the good, the bad, and the expensive – because I want you to know that there’s hope. Truly conscious, ethical marketing mentors exist, and they’re not hiding behind a paywall that requires a second mortgage to access. They’re out there, offering genuine value without breaking the bank.
My experience taught me a valuable lesson: in the world of marketing mentors, the most expensive option isn’t always the best. Sometimes, the most valuable guidance comes at a price that respects both your budget and your values. So if you’re feeling overwhelmed and tempted by those flashy high-ticket offers, take a deep breath. There’s another way, and I’m living proof that it works.
When Desperation Meets Manipulation: The High-Ticket Trap
A couple of years ago, I dipped my toes into the world of impostor syndrome mentoring. What I discovered was both eye-opening and heartbreaking. Many of the women I spoke with had their own horror stories about high-ticket coaches. These weren’t just anecdotes; they were cautionary tales of new business owners plunging into debt, chasing the promise of success.
Despite the hefty price tags, these women got very little in return. Why? Because these programs were often overcrowded calls masquerading as personalised coaching. There was simply no room for the individual attention these budding solopreneurs desperately needed.
Let’s break down why these high-ticket programs often fall flat:
- 1) No one can promise you results. Consuming a course is easy. But digesting and applying what you have learned is the real graft.
- 2) Expensive, famous coaches often subcontract their group programs to other, less experienced coaches. You sign up thinking you’ll be learning from the master herself, only to find out you’ve been pawned off to a junior coach who’s barely a step ahead of you.
- 3) Masterminds from famous people are often run in huge groups where you have very little access to the coach, and therefore time to ask questions or get the individualised help you need..
- 4) Many of these coaches aren’t really interested in your success. They’re interested in your wallet. You’re not a person to nurture; you’re a lead to convert into their next high-ticket offer.
The bottom line? These high-ticket programs often leave you feeling more like an impostor than ever, with a maxed-out credit card to boot. It’s a painful lesson that many learn the hard way.
The high ticket coach I worked with told me that my client’s financial situation wasn’t my problem. Contrast this with the fact that the two ethical marketing coaches I have worked with recently always ask if you can afford their programme without causing yourself hardship before you sign up.
Whatever your situation, as a business owner, income is likely to be a priority for you. If it’s the only priority, that’s when we run into trouble. That’s where we see businesses that prioritise profits before people and we all know how that goes. As conscious business owners, only focusing on money isn’t enough of a driver for us, so it would be unsustainable over the long term if this was our only priority. Caroline Leon
The Siren Song of Six-Figure Promises: My Brush with High-Ticket Marketing
A few years ago I attended a free all day workshop in a posh London hotel, a day supposedly designed to teach us how to market ourselves better. What actually happened was no real useful info was given. It was just designed to sell us a very expensive group program. The cost of the year long group program was £1000 a month, with a 12 month contract you could not get out of.
I very nearly signed up despite the eye watering cost, because the woman running the program was so good at promising results. Thankfully something stopped me. I’m currently in a small conscious marketing group mastermind with Caroline Leon. There are only 20 people in the program, and I pay £115 a month for it. I love this group because it connects me with like minded people and it keeps me accountable, and it also feels doable and not overwhelming.
In this group I met a wonderful mindset coach called Betty Cottam Bertels. Betty introduced me to another ethical marketing mentor called Tag Hargrave. I joined Betty on a day-long workshop in London with Tad a few months ago, one that he runs on a “pay what you can afford” basis.
Betty introduced the day by telling her story of having signed up to a very expensive business coaching program, only to become really disillusioned when she realised that she had no access to the front woman: instead the course was facilitated by sub-contracted coaches with less experience who did not fit her needs.
When I asked her which program this was, it turned out to be the very one I had nearly signed up for. I felt like I had a very lucky escape.
Trauma-Targeted Marketing: The Uncomfortable Truth
High-ticket coaches often sell to your trauma. Why? Because it works. They know that when you’re feeling vulnerable, stressed, and desperate for change, you’re more likely to reach for what seems like a lifeline – even if it comes with a huge price tag. They use language that triggers your pain points, promising to solve all your problems if only you invest in their “exclusive” program. It’s manipulative, it’s unethical, and it’s downright harmful. These coaches aren’t interested in your healing; they’re interested in your wallet. They exploit your past hurts and current struggles to make you feel like their overpriced program is the only solution. But here’s the truth: real healing and business growth don’t come from a magic bullet solution. They come from consistent effort, genuine support, and ethical practices that honour your journey, not exploit it.
As George Kao explains in this blog post:
Sadly, much of the persuasion psychology being used (and taught) in marketing – the stoking of fear, uncertainty, doubt (FUD) – “works” on people with traumatic backgrounds… because they’ve invested so much in the guru’s advice, they might experience the sunk cost fallacy. “The teacher must know better than me… otherwise, they couldn’t charge so much money. I should’ve succeeded like them by now.” George Kao
George also explains that setting yourself small, achievable goals, builds up your confidence, whereas setting sky high unachievable one has the opposite effect.
If you’re running a heart-centred holistic business, listen up: those manipulative, salesy tactics might seem tempting when you’re desperate for clients, but they’re damaging for your business’s long-term health. They erode the very foundation of what makes your work special : trust.
Your clients come to you for healing, for support, for a safe space. The moment you start using pushy sales tactics, you’re betraying that trust. It’s like offering a warm hug with one hand and a sales pitch with the other. It just doesn’t work.
These aggressive marketing strategies aren’t just misaligned with your business – they’re misaligned with your soul. They go against everything you stand for, everything that made you choose this beautiful, challenging path of holistic care in the first place.
George Kao calls these strategies “marketing to the lizard brain” and explains why it feels misaligned, why it harms your business, and even society as a whole.
By inciting the people’s lizard brain, marketers (and politicians) do in fact gain more control over their audience in the short-term. It’s power-over others, rather than empowerment of others. George Kao
But here’s the good news: there’s another way. A way that’s as authentic as your most heartfelt client session. A way that’s as true as your commitment to healing and growth.
This path might not promise overnight success or six-figure months, but it promises something far more valuable: a business that’s a true extension of your healing work. A business that attracts clients who resonate with your authentic self, not a manufactured marketing persona.
So, take a deep breath. Release the pressure to conform to aggressive marketing tactics. Your business can thrive without compromising your values. In fact, it will thrive because you’re honouring those values. And that, my fellow holistic practitioner, is the true path to long-term success and fulfilment.
Having worked with authentic marketing coaches for 4 years, I can see manipulative tactics from a mile. And I truly believe that these tactics belong to the past. That they, and the people who use them, are dinosaurs, destined to become extinct.
The Ethical Marketing Oasis: Finding Genuine Mentors
Finding my first ethical marketing mentor felt like stumbling upon an oasis in a desert of manipulation. Such people are out there, and working with them is a game-changer. These are the folks who genuinely care about your success, not just their bank balance. They’re transparent about their methods, clear about their pricing, and they won’t promise you the moon and stars overnight. Instead, they offer real, actionable advice that aligns with your values as a heart-centred business owner.
They give away tons of value for free or at low cost, because their goal is to serve, not just to sell. When you find these gems, it’s like a weight lifts off your shoulders. Suddenly, marketing doesn’t feel icky anymore. You’re not compromising your integrity for success. You’re growing your business in a way that feels authentic and sustainable. And the best part? These ethical mentors often charge a fraction of what the high-ticket gurus do.
Working with ethical coaches has been like a breath of fresh air for my business – and my sanity. Instead of feeling pressured and overwhelmed, I’ve found myself actually enjoying the process of growing my business. These genuine mentors have helped me tap into my authentic voice, allowing me to market my services in a way that feels aligned with my values as a holistic practitioner. I’m no longer trying to squeeze myself into a one-size-fits-all marketing mould that leaves me feeling yucky.
The impact? My business has grown organically, attracting clients who resonate with my authentic approach. I’m earning more whilst working less hours, without burning out or compromising my integrity. But more than that, I’ve regained my confidence and joy in my work. These ethical coaches have shown me that it’s possible to be successful without resorting to manipulative tactics. They’ve given me practical, sustainable strategies that I can implement at my own pace, respecting my neurodivergent needs and my commitment to my family.
The best part? I’m not just learning how to market better – I’m learning how to build a business that truly reflects who I am and the change I want to see in the world.
The Ethical Marketing Checklist: What to Look For in a Coach
Having worked with 3 different ethical marketing coaches here are the things I have found they have in common:
- Transparency & authenticity: They are clear about their methods, pricing, and expected outcomes, and open about their own qualifications and experience. They never make over inflated promises or guarantees.
- Ethical practises: They avoid manipulative of deceptive tactics, such as time pressure (buy it now for X or it will never be available again), or fake inflated prices (“sign up now and get this (fake) bonuses priced at thousand of pounds/dollars) They promote truthful and accurate marketing messages.
- Client centred: They focus on supporting their audience and clients, not just what’s profitable. You can feel it in their presence and writing: serving is their overarching goal.
- They are value-driven: They emphasise creating genuine value for customers, and encourages sustainable, long-term growth over quick wins
- Nurture: they nurture their audience by giving away valuable content on their website, their social media channels, low cost offers, books etc. They give away so much that if you are able to keep yourself accountable on your own, you could learn enough to transform your business from their free or low cost content alone. Most of their social media posts are about this nurturing, with the odd course/workshop offer in between.
- (Note: This is in stark contrast to high ticket coaches. I have found that these never give away anything of value unless you buy their course. They are masters in the art of running “free” webinars, workshops or challenges, where they talk about their success and clients’ success stories, whilst never telling you how to do it. It is purely a promotion exercise. Their social media is not about nurturing it’s about selling.)
- Holistic Perspective: They consider the impact of their marketing strategies on society. They encourages socially responsible marketing practices
- Ethical Pricing: They charge fair prices for their services and are transparent about costs. Ethical pricing really boils down to: 1) Can you earn enough to make your business sustainable from it? and 2) Can the people buying your course afford to do this without hardship, and recoup the cost of your course within about 6 months?
Ethical and accessible pricing is super important to me. So much so that I get told regularly that I don’t charge enough for what I offer. I love it when that happens because that’s actually one of my primary goals with everything I create — to give tons of value for the most affordable price possible. Caroline Leon (read Caroline’s article about this here)
The Principles of Ethical/Conscious Businesses
When we change the way we do business, we change the world. Caroline Leon
A conscious business owner, according to Caroline Leon :
- Operates with integrity and knows that how we sell matters.
- Wants her business to be a force for good and knows that how we do business is a key part of that.
- Puts the needs of the customer above the goal of making the sale and is willing to turn down a sale when it’s clear that what she is offering is not a good fit for the buyer.
- Prioritises the cultivation of trust and connection between herself and her audience.
- Rejects the use of manipulative marketing tactics to pressure her audience into buying.
- Constantly seeks to ensure her products and services are of real value to her audience.
- Makes positive impact the goal of everything she creates.
- Is completely transparent when selling and uses no tricks or gimmicks to hide that fact. Instead simply presenting what’s on offer in a clear and honest way.
- Works towards sustainability because she knows that an unsustainable business in the long term helps no-one.
The 8 practises of authentic business by George Kao:
- Joyful Productivity: the ability to consistently work in a focused and joyful way. Balancing rest and action, with a spirit of playfulness throughout.
- Healthy Money Habits: It is important to become aware of our inner relationship to money (our thoughts and emotions) and our persistent behaviours with regards to money.
- Authentic Content: The habit of creating content will help you to keep exploring your core message and strengthening your authentic voice.
- Paid Content Distribution: If you’re not using paid ads of some kind, you are holding yourself back from reaching the thousands of people who need your message and voice.
- Collaborations: Seek out collaborations because it’s a good way to grow an aligned audience. Good collaborations create a lot more benefit than the effort takes
- Audience Research: When you have a product that is well-matched to someone’s wants, the thing almost sells itself. Neglect this and you may well be building the wrong audience.
- Rhythm of Gentle Launches: Start a routine of “making offers”, in other words, letting your audience know about your products and services.
- Mastery of Your Craft: The most grounded way to excel in one’s work is to notice the impact your work is making on your clients, and then make adjustments based on those observations.
Affordable Wisdom: Ethical Coaches Who Won’t Break the Bank
Check their website/social media channels and see if you resonate with their approach. All 3 offer tons of free content, as well as low cost workshops/courses if you’d like to see if they are a fit.
Read my previous articles about what I learnt by working with George and Caroline below:
Most entrepreneurs I know feel torn between either doing marketing that feels good (but doesn’t work) or marketing that works (but doesn’t feel good). I am suggesting that there’s a way to approach marketing that actually works better than the pushy and manipulative approaches you hate and that feels genuinely good to all involved. Tad Hargraves
Conclusion
The journey from overwhelm to authentic marketing isn’t always easy, but it’s infinitely more rewarding than falling prey to high-ticket, manipulative coaches. As conscious business owners, we have a responsibility to ourselves and our clients to seek out and support ethical marketing practices.
Remember, high pricing is never proof of higher value – it’s simply a marketing choice. There are brilliant, ethical marketing mentors out there who offer incredible value at accessible prices. They prioritise your growth over their profit, and they understand that true success comes from alignment with your values, not just your bank balance.
I hope my story and insights help you navigate the sometimes murky waters of business coaching. Trust your intuition, seek out mentors who resonate with your values, and never compromise your integrity for the promise of quick success.
I believe that we can create a new paradigm of ethical, heart-centred marketing that serves both our businesses and our souls. After all, isn’t that why we started our holistic businesses in the first place?
I’d love to hear how reading this article felt for you – simply comment below.
Great article, Sophie and I agree so wholeheartedly! I follow those 3 ethical marketing coaches too and absolutely LOVE the value, the love, the care and ethics they bring.
I love all the examples and listing Caroline’s and George’s main points. May coaches find this very valuable!